The biggest mistake new podcasters make

Jay-Jay Feeney • 21 April 2026

Why the Best Podcasts Don’t Sound Like Everyone Else

There are 5 million podcasts in the world, and plenty of them are well-made, well-edited, and full of good content.

So why do only some podcasts really grow?


Because the ones that cut through usually offer something original.


One of the biggest mistakes new podcasters make is trying to copy a successful show. Same format. Same style. Same kind of guests. Same energy. But listeners can tell when a podcast feels like a lesser version of something they already know.

You do not need to be the next Joe Rogan or Jay Shetty. You need to be more you.


The strongest podcasts are built on what no one else can replicate: your experience, your point of view, your stories, your personality, and the way you see your topic.

That is what makes a show memorable.

Yes, your podcast still needs to feel relevant to your audience. Your title, artwork, and topics need to pull people in. But once they hit play, there should be something distinct about what you deliver.

Something they cannot get anywhere else.


If your podcast sounds like every other show in your niche, that is a problem. But if it sounds unmistakably like you, that is your advantage.

In a noisy podcast world, copying is not the path to growth. Originality is.


Inspired by Jeremy Enns of Podcast Marketing Academy — his Scrappy Podcasting newsletter is well worth a read if you're serious about growing your show.

by Jay-Jay Feeney 16 September 2025
WANT TO GROW YOUR PODCAST?
by Jay-Jay Feeney 15 September 2025
Here’s What You Need to Know
by Jay-Jay Feeney 30 August 2025
HOW TO NAME YOUR PODCAST
by Jay-Jay Feeney 7 February 2025
HOT TIPS
by Dom Harvey 28 January 2025
HOW DO I ATTRACT LISTENERS TO MY PODCAST?
by Jay-Jay Feeney 8 January 2025
People often ask us if they can use their favourite song as the opening music for their podcast. Spoiler alert: The answer is... No
Welcome to “Starting a podcast 101.” Use this to create and launch your own podcast today in 8 easy
10 November 2024
Welcome to “Starting a podcast 101.” Use this to create and launch your own podcast today in 8 easy steps for a total cost of ZERO DOLLARS!
A podcast is a digital audio or video file that can be played or downloaded from the internet. It’s
9 November 2024
A podcast is a digital audio or video file that can be played or downloaded from the internet. It’s basically an audio show.